Best Solar Powered Video Doorbells: Smart Security For Your Home

That moment when you hear a rustle at the door, but you’re stuck in the middle of a crucial work call or deep into a movie marathon. You instinctively reach for your phone, hoping to catch a glimpse of who’s there without interrupting your flow, and that’s exactly where the magic of a smart video doorbell truly shines. But navigating the world of home security can feel a bit like deciphering a secret code, especially when you’re looking for that perfect blend of convenience and sustainability.

That’s why we’ve done the legwork for you, diving deep into the features and performance of the latest models to bring you our guide to the best solar powered video doorbells. We know you want a reliable way to keep an eye on your front porch, get instant alerts, and maybe even have a friendly chat with visitors, all without the hassle of frequent battery changes or messy wiring. So, let’s explore how these innovative devices can upgrade your home security and simplify your life.

Before moving into the review of the best solar powered video doorbells, let’s check out some of the relevant products from Amazon:

Last update on 2025-09-03 / #ad / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Table of Contents

Never Miss a Visitor (or a Package!) Again: Your Friendly Guide to Solar-Powered Video Doorbells

Remember the good old days when a doorbell just meant someone was at the door? Now, it’s a portal to your home’s security, a way to greet guests from miles away, and your silent guardian against porch pirates. But let’s be honest, the thought of another battery to charge or a hardwired connection to figure out can feel like a hassle. That’s where a little bit of sunshine and some clever tech come in to save the day! We’re diving into a world where your doorbell powers itself, making your life just a little bit easier and a whole lot more secure.

Imagine this: no more scrambling to find the right charger when your doorbell’s battery is flashing red, or no need to hire an electrician just to get a video feed. Solar-powered video doorbells harness the sun’s energy, meaning they can stay charged and operational almost indefinitely, especially in sunny climates. In fact, with sufficient sunlight exposure, many of these devices can achieve a near-continuous charge, reducing your reliance on mains power and offering a truly set-it-and-forget-it solution for your front step. This eco-friendly approach not only saves you time but also contributes to a greener lifestyle.

So, what exactly makes these sunny sentinels so appealing? Beyond the self-charging convenience, you get all the smart features you’ve come to expect. Crystal-clear HD video, motion detection alerts sent straight to your phone, two-way audio so you can chat with visitors, and often, night vision for round-the-clock monitoring. Whether you’re at work, on vacation, or just in the backyard, you’ll always know who’s at your door. This level of connectivity and control is a game-changer for modern homeowners, providing peace of mind that’s hard to put a price on.

If you’re tired of battery anxiety and looking for a smart, sustainable way to enhance your home security, then exploring the best solar powered video doorbells is definitely for you. It’s about embracing technology that works for you, effortlessly and reliably. We’ll walk you through what to look for, the top contenders in the market, and how to choose the perfect solar-powered companion to keep your home safe and connected, all powered by the sun’s natural energy. Get ready to see your doorstep in a whole new light!

Best Solar Powered Video Doorbells – Reviewed

Ring Video Doorbell 3 Plus

This doorbell is a solid contender for anyone looking for a reliable, feature-rich solar-powered video doorbell. The added benefit of the “Pre-Roll” feature is a game-changer, allowing users to see what happened before the motion was detected, which can be incredibly useful for catching those quick, sneaky package thieves or understanding the full context of an event. The video quality is crisp, and the two-way audio is clear, making communication with visitors a breeze. Setup is generally straightforward, and it integrates seamlessly with other Ring products for those already invested in the ecosystem.

The solar charging aspect is a definite plus, reducing the need for frequent battery changes, though in areas with less consistent sunlight, a manual recharge might still be occasionally necessary. The motion detection zones are customizable, which helps to minimize false alerts from passing cars or swaying trees. While it’s not the absolute cheapest option on the market, the combination of its advanced features, robust build quality, and the convenience of solar charging makes the Ring Video Doorbell 3 Plus a worthwhile investment for enhanced home security.

Arlo Essential Video Doorbell Wire-Free with Solar Panel

Arlo has made a name for itself with high-quality smart home security, and this video doorbell continues that tradition. The wire-free design offers incredible installation flexibility, and the included solar panel ensures that your doorbell is powered up and ready to capture any activity. The wide viewing angle provides an excellent panoramic view of your doorstep, so you won’t miss a thing. Plus, the video resolution is sharp, offering clear images even in low-light conditions, which is crucial for round-the-clock security.

What really sets this doorbell apart is its intelligent detection capabilities. It can differentiate between people, packages, animals, and vehicles, allowing for more targeted notifications and fewer annoying false alarms. The subscription service, while an additional cost, unlocks even more advanced features like cloud storage and person detection, which some users will find indispensable. For a sleek, powerful, and solar-assisted video doorbell, the Arlo Essential is a strong recommendation.

Google Nest Doorbell (Battery) with Solar Charger

For those embedded in the Google ecosystem, the Nest Doorbell (Battery) is a natural fit, especially when paired with its dedicated solar charger. This doorbell offers excellent video quality with intelligent alerts that are genuinely useful, distinguishing between familiar and unfamiliar faces, which adds a significant layer of personalized security. The design is also quite understated and modern, blending well with most home exteriors. The battery life is impressive even without the solar charger, but the continuous trickle charge from the sun is a fantastic convenience.

The integration with Google Assistant and other Google Nest devices is seamless, allowing for easy viewing of live feeds on smart displays or even getting voice alerts. The setup process is intuitive, and the app provides a user-friendly experience for managing settings and reviewing footage. While the subscription for extended storage and advanced features is a consideration, the core functionality of the doorbell, combined with the reliable solar charging option, makes it a compelling choice for Google-centric smart homes.

Eufy Security Video Doorbell 2K (Battery-Powered, with Solar Panel option)

Eufy is known for offering a great balance of features and value, and this video doorbell is no exception, especially with the solar panel accessory available. The 2K resolution delivers incredibly detailed video, capturing fine nuances that other doorbells might miss. The wide field of view ensures that the entire porch area is covered. What’s particularly appealing about Eufy is its commitment to local storage for footage, meaning no mandatory monthly fees for accessing your recordings, which is a huge plus for many consumers.

The battery-powered nature means flexible installation, and the optional solar panel keeps it topped up effortlessly. The AI-powered human detection is quite effective at reducing irrelevant alerts, and the two-way audio is clear for communication. While you might need to manually recharge the battery on occasion if sunlight is consistently low, the overall performance and the freedom from ongoing subscription costs make the Eufy Video Doorbell a smart and cost-effective choice for many homeowners looking for a robust solar-powered solution.

Swann BuddyCam Video Doorbell with Solar Panel

The Swann BuddyCam presents a solid, no-frills approach to solar-powered video doorbells, focusing on core functionality and reliable performance. The video quality is good, providing clear images of visitors, and the motion detection is reasonably sensitive, ensuring you’re alerted to activity at your door. The two-way audio is functional, allowing for basic communication. The real draw here is the simplicity and the inclusion of a solar panel, making it a set-it-and-forget-it option for many users who don’t want complex integrations or subscription services.

Installation is typically straightforward, and the dedicated app is easy to navigate. While it may not boast the same level of advanced AI detection or panoramic viewing angles as some of its more premium competitors, the Swann BuddyCam excels at its primary job: providing a solar-powered way to see and speak to visitors at your door. For those prioritizing ease of use, a lack of subscription fees, and consistent solar charging without needing the absolute cutting edge of technology, this doorbell is a commendable and budget-friendly option.

The Bright Future: Why Your Home Needs a Solar-Powered Video Doorbell

Ever felt that pang of anxiety when you miss a package delivery because you were in the shower or out for a bit? Or perhaps you’ve wondered who was at your door when you were on vacation, hoping it wasn’t an unsolicited salesperson or something more concerning. This is precisely where the magic of a solar-powered video doorbell shines. It’s more than just a gadget; it’s a peace-of-mind enhancer, giving you eyes on your doorstep 24/7 without the hassle of battery changes or complicated wiring. Imagine the convenience of knowing instantly if that Amazon delivery has arrived safely or if your kids have returned from school, all from the palm of your hand.

The beauty of a solar-powered video doorbell lies in its seamless integration into your daily life, especially the “solar-powered” aspect. Forget the recurring chore of replacing batteries or the worry of them dying at a crucial moment. These smart devices harness the sun’s energy, meaning they are largely self-sufficient. This not only saves you time and money but also makes them an environmentally conscious choice. Think of it as a set-it-and-forget-it solution that continuously powers your home’s security, ensuring you never miss an important visitor or delivery, no matter how long you’re away.

When we talk about the “best solar powered video doorbells,” we’re referring to devices that offer crystal-clear HD video, wide-angle views to capture everything that happens on your porch, and reliable two-way audio for communication. These features allow you to greet guests remotely, deter potential intruders with your voice, or simply confirm a delivery person’s identity. It’s like having a vigilant doorman, always on duty, providing an extra layer of security and convenience that traditional doorbells simply can’t match.

Ultimately, investing in a solar-powered video doorbell is an investment in your home’s safety, your convenience, and your peace of mind. It’s about being connected to your home, even when you’re not there, and ensuring that no important moment at your front door goes unnoticed. Whether you’re a busy parent, a frequent traveler, or simply someone who values security and modern technology, a solar-powered video doorbell offers a smart, sustainable, and incredibly practical solution for the modern homeowner.

Choosing the Right Solar Panel for Your Doorbell

When selecting a solar-powered video doorbell, the integrated solar panel is a crucial component to consider. Not all solar panels are created equal, and their efficiency directly impacts how often your doorbell needs manual charging. Look for panels made from high-efficiency monocrystalline silicon, which generally perform better in a wider range of lighting conditions compared to polycrystalline silicon. Consider the physical dimensions of the panel as well; a larger surface area usually translates to more sunlight absorption and faster charging.

The wattage of the solar panel is another important spec. While most video doorbells come with an integrated panel, some might offer options for a larger, external solar panel. If your home has limited direct sunlight exposure, opting for a higher wattage panel can significantly improve its charging capabilities. It’s also worth checking the panel’s weather resistance, ensuring it’s designed to withstand rain, snow, and UV exposure without degradation.

Pay attention to the connector type if you are considering an external solar panel. Ensure it’s compatible with the specific doorbell model you choose. Some manufacturers offer proprietary connectors, while others use more universal options. Reading user reviews can provide valuable insights into the real-world performance of the solar panel and how well it keeps the doorbell charged, especially in less than ideal weather.

Understanding Connectivity and Smart Features

Beyond the solar power aspect, the connectivity and smart features of a video doorbell are paramount to its usefulness. Most solar-powered models connect to your home Wi-Fi network, allowing you to receive alerts and view live feeds on your smartphone or tablet. Look for models that support dual-band Wi-Fi (2.4GHz and 5GHz) for a more stable and faster connection, especially if you have a crowded Wi-Fi environment.

Consider the smart home ecosystem compatibility. If you use platforms like Amazon Alexa or Google Assistant, choose a doorbell that integrates seamlessly. This allows for voice commands, such as “show me the front door,” and can trigger other smart home devices. Some doorbells also offer integration with Apple HomeKit, providing another layer of smart home convenience.

Advanced features like customizable motion detection zones, package detection, and person detection can significantly enhance security and reduce unnecessary notifications. Two-way audio quality is also important for clear communication with visitors. Lastly, investigate the cloud storage options. Many doorbells offer free limited cloud storage for event clips, while others require a subscription for extended history and advanced features. Evaluate these options based on your needs and budget.

Installation and Mounting Options

The installation process for solar-powered video doorbells is generally straightforward, but understanding the available mounting options can ensure optimal placement for both the doorbell and its solar panel. Most come with a mounting bracket that attaches to your existing doorbell wiring or can be mounted directly onto a flat surface. Ensure the bracket is durable and made from weather-resistant materials.

For optimal solar charging, the doorbell and its panel should ideally face south or west in the Northern Hemisphere, or north or west in the Southern Hemisphere, to capture the most direct sunlight throughout the day. If your current doorbell location doesn’t offer ideal sun exposure, some models allow for the solar panel to be mounted separately in a more advantageous spot. Check if the kit includes extension cables for the solar panel if this is a possibility.

Consider the power source of your existing doorbell. Many solar-powered models can also be hardwired into your existing doorbell transformer, providing a reliable backup power source and ensuring continuous charging even during extended periods of low sunlight. This dual-power approach offers the best of both worlds for consistent operation and peace of mind.

Battery Life and Performance in Low Light Conditions

One of the primary advantages of solar-powered video doorbells is their ability to remain operational without frequent battery changes. However, understanding their battery life and how they perform in less-than-ideal lighting is crucial for long-term satisfaction. Most manufacturers provide an estimated battery life, but this can vary significantly based on usage patterns, Wi-Fi signal strength, and the efficiency of the solar charging.

When evaluating performance in low light conditions, pay attention to reviews that discuss how well the solar panel maintains a charge during cloudy days or periods of heavy rain. Some solar panels are designed with better low-light harvesting capabilities, which can be a significant advantage in regions with less consistent sunshine. Look for models that clearly state their charging performance even in diffuse light.

It’s also important to consider the capacity of the internal battery. A larger battery will provide more buffer for days with minimal solar input, ensuring the doorbell continues to function. Some advanced models even allow you to monitor the battery level and solar charging status directly through the associated app, giving you greater transparency into the system’s performance.

Absolutely! Here’s your buying guide for the best solar powered video doorbells, written in a friendly and helpful tone.

Your Guide to the Best Solar Powered Video Doorbells

Hey there! So, you’re thinking about upgrading your home security with a video doorbell, and you’re smart enough to be looking at solar-powered options. That’s awesome! Not only do you get the convenience of seeing who’s at your door from anywhere, but you also get to wave goodbye to battery changes and hello to eco-friendly power. It’s a win-win, really. But with so many options out there, how do you even begin to choose the best solar powered video doorbells for your specific needs? Don’t worry, I’ve got your back. Think of me as your friendly guide, here to walk you through the process, so you can make an informed decision without all the tech jargon overwhelm. We’ll break down what really matters, what’s just a fancy feature, and how to find that perfect balance of smart tech and sustainable power.

1. Solar Panel Performance: Is It Really Enough?

Let’s talk about the heart of the matter – that solar panel. When you’re looking for the best solar powered video doorbells, you absolutely have to consider how well that little panel is going to keep your doorbell charged. Some come with a built-in panel, while others offer an optional, larger detachable one. Think about where your front door actually gets sunlight. If it’s tucked away in a shady corner, a tiny, integrated panel might struggle to keep up, especially during those shorter winter days.

You’ll want to check the wattage of the solar panel if it’s listed. Generally, the higher the wattage, the faster and more reliably it will charge. Also, consider if it’s weather-resistant and how easily it can be repositioned. Some systems allow you to angle the panel towards the sun, which can make a huge difference. Don’t be afraid to look at reviews that specifically mention battery life and charging consistency, as that’s a real-world indicator of how good that solar performance is.

2. Video Quality and Field of View: What Can You Actually See?

This is pretty straightforward, but incredibly important. You want to be able to clearly see who’s at your door, right? So, pay close attention to the video resolution. Most modern video doorbells offer at least 1080p HD, which is a good starting point. But if you can spring for 2K or even 4K, you’ll get a much sharper image, making it easier to identify faces and details.

Beyond just resolution, the field of view is crucial. Think of it like this: a wider field of view means you can see more of what’s happening. Some doorbells have a narrow, almost tunnel-like view, while others offer a much broader, almost panoramic perspective. For a video doorbell, you want to see not just who’s standing directly on your porch, but also the package left to the side or if someone is lurking a bit further away. Look for specs like 160 degrees or more for a good all-around view.

3. Motion Detection and Alerts: Getting Notified About What Matters

You don’t want to be bombarded with notifications every time a leaf blows across your porch, but you definitely want to know if someone’s actually approaching your door. This is where motion detection technology comes into play. The best solar powered video doorbells will offer customizable motion zones, meaning you can draw specific areas on the screen where you want the doorbell to detect movement. This way, you can ignore the busy street in the background and focus on your pathway.

Many also offer AI-powered person detection, which is a game-changer. Instead of just detecting any movement, it can specifically identify humans. This significantly reduces false alerts from cars, pets, or even shadows. When it comes to alerts, you’ll want to see how quickly they arrive on your phone and if there are options for different alert types, like motion events versus actual doorbell rings.

4. Two-Way Audio: Having a Chat From Anywhere

This is one of those features that you might not think you need until you have it, and then you can’t imagine living without it. Two-way audio lets you speak to whoever is at your door, and they can speak back to you, all through your smartphone app. It’s super handy for a lot of reasons.

Imagine you’re expecting a delivery and you’re not home. You can tell the delivery person exactly where to leave the package. Or maybe you’re just not comfortable opening the door to a stranger; you can have a conversation and decide whether or not to let them in. Good quality audio is key here, so check reviews for clarity and any mention of background noise cancellation. You want to hear and be heard clearly!

5. Storage Options: Where Do Your Recordings Go?

When it comes to storing the video footage from your doorbell, you’ve generally got two main options: cloud storage or local storage. Cloud storage usually involves a subscription fee, but it offers the convenience of accessing your recordings from anywhere and often provides more advanced features like longer storage periods. It’s like having your own private video vault online.

Local storage, on the other hand, typically uses an SD card inserted directly into the doorbell or a base station. This means you own the footage outright, and there are no recurring monthly costs. However, if the doorbell or SD card is stolen or damaged, you could lose your recordings. Consider which approach aligns best with your budget and your privacy preferences. Many of the best solar powered video doorbells offer a combination of both, giving you flexibility.

6. Connectivity and App Experience: Staying Connected Seamlessly

For any smart home device to work well, it needs to be reliably connected to your Wi-Fi network. Make sure the doorbell you’re considering supports your Wi-Fi frequency (2.4GHz is common and offers better range, while 5GHz can be faster but has a shorter range). Some doorbells also have an option for a wired connection to your existing doorbell wiring, which can provide a more stable power source and connectivity, even if you’re relying on solar as a backup.

Equally important is the accompanying app. This is your command center for everything. Is the app easy to navigate? Does it provide clear live feeds and easy access to recordings? Are the notification settings robust and customizable? A clunky or unreliable app can quickly turn an exciting smart home gadget into a frustrating experience, so take a peek at app reviews if you can.

7. Durability and Weather Resistance: Built to Last

Your video doorbell is going to be living outside, exposed to the elements, so its durability and weather resistance are paramount. You don’t want something that’s going to conk out after the first heavy rain or extreme temperature change. Look for an IP rating, which is a standard way of measuring a device’s protection against dust and water.

An IP65 rating is generally considered good for outdoor devices, meaning it’s protected against dust ingress and low-pressure water jets. Higher ratings like IP66 or IP67 offer even greater protection. Consider the materials used in its construction too. A sturdy, well-built doorbell will not only withstand the weather but also deter potential intruders better. Think about what the climate is like where you live – are you dealing with harsh sun, heavy snow, or frequent downpours? Choose a doorbell that’s built to handle it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I really rely on a solar-powered video doorbell without much sun?

That’s a great question, and it’s completely understandable to wonder about that! Most solar-powered video doorbells are designed to be pretty efficient. They typically have a built-in rechargeable battery that stores the solar energy. This means even if you have a few cloudy days in a row, the doorbell should still have enough power to operate. The solar panel’s main job is to keep that battery topped up, so it’s less about constant direct sunlight and more about having some exposure over time.

Think of it like charging your phone with a solar charger. You don’t need direct sun all day to keep it going; a little bit of charging each day will maintain the battery level. For most people, the solar panel is more than enough to negate the need for manual charging, especially if the doorbell isn’t constantly recording or using a lot of power. If you live in a very shaded area or have prolonged periods of darkness, you might want to check the specific product’s battery life and charging requirements, but generally, they’re quite capable.

What happens if my solar doorbell runs out of power?

Don’t worry, most solar-powered doorbells have a backup plan if the solar charging isn’t quite keeping up. Many come with a USB port, allowing you to easily charge the internal battery manually if needed. This is usually a pretty simple process – just plug in a standard USB cable and let it charge for a few hours. It’s a good idea to keep the charging cable handy, just in case you notice the battery level dropping and want to give it a boost.

So, while the solar aspect is fantastic for convenience and reducing your electricity bill, it’s not a system that will leave you powerless. It’s more about minimizing the effort you need to put in. You can check the battery status through the doorbell’s companion app, so you’ll usually get a heads-up before it gets critically low. Most users find that the solar power is more than sufficient, but having that manual charging option provides extra peace of mind.

Are solar-powered video doorbells as good as wired ones?

That’s a really common point of comparison, and the answer is generally yes, they can be just as good, if not better in some ways! The core functionality – clear video, two-way audio, motion detection – is typically excellent on modern solar-powered doorbells. The main difference is how they get their power. Wired doorbells rely on your home’s existing doorbell wiring, which can sometimes be a bit fiddly to set up if the wiring is old or incompatible.

Solar-powered doorbells offer incredible flexibility in placement. You can install them almost anywhere with a bit of light exposure, without needing to worry about running wires through your walls. For many people, this ease of installation and the ongoing benefit of not needing to charge them manually makes them a really attractive option. Performance-wise, you’re generally getting a very similar, high-quality experience.

How do I know if my installation spot gets enough sun?

Figuring out the best spot for your solar-powered doorbell is simpler than you might think! Generally, you’ll want to find a location that gets at least a few hours of direct sunlight each day. This doesn’t have to be all day, long, continuous sun. Even an hour or two of good sunlight can make a big difference in keeping the battery topped up.

A good way to test this is to temporarily place the doorbell (or just the solar panel part if it’s detachable) in different spots for a day or two and see how the battery indicator behaves through the app. Look for areas that aren’t heavily shaded by trees, overhangs, or other buildings for most of the day. South-facing walls in the Northern Hemisphere typically get the most sun, but even east or west-facing locations can work well depending on your local climate and the time of year.

Will bad weather affect the solar charging performance?

It’s definitely a valid concern, especially if you live somewhere with frequent rain or snow! During periods of heavy cloud cover or snow, the solar panel won’t be able to generate as much power. However, as we mentioned before, the built-in battery is there to help bridge those gaps. The doorbell is designed to store energy, so it should continue to function even during prolonged bad weather.

The key is that the solar panel acts as a consistent trickle charger. Even on a mostly cloudy day, it’s still collecting some ambient light and converting it into energy. So, while charging might be slower, it’s still happening. Most users find that the battery capacity is sufficient to last through a few days of poor weather without needing a manual charge, especially if the battery was fully charged beforehand.

How often do I need to clean the solar panel?

You really only need to clean the solar panel occasionally to keep it working at its best, much like you’d clean a window. Dust, pollen, bird droppings, or even cobwebs can accumulate over time and slightly reduce the panel’s efficiency. Think of it as giving it a quick spruce-up to ensure it’s soaking up as much sunlight as possible.

A good rule of thumb is to give it a quick wipe down maybe once or twice a year, or whenever you notice it looks a bit grimy. You can usually just use a soft, damp cloth. Avoid using any harsh chemicals or abrasive materials, as these could potentially scratch the panel. Most of the time, a gentle wipe with a damp microfiber cloth is all it takes to get it back to optimal performance.

Are there any privacy concerns with solar-powered video doorbells?

Privacy is a big consideration for everyone nowadays, and it’s great that you’re thinking about it! When it comes to solar-powered video doorbells, the privacy features are very similar to their wired counterparts. Reputable brands invest heavily in secure encryption for your video feeds, meaning only you (and whoever you choose to share access with) can view the footage.

Most of these doorbells come with apps that offer granular control over motion detection zones and recording schedules. This means you can customize when and where the camera records, helping to ensure it’s not capturing unnecessary footage. Plus, with the solar aspect, you’re not introducing any new network vulnerabilities compared to a standard Wi-Fi video doorbell. It’s always a good idea to use a strong, unique password for your Wi-Fi network and your doorbell’s account to further enhance your privacy.

Final Thoughts

So, you’ve explored the world of solar-powered security, and hopefully, you’re feeling pretty empowered to take that next step. Remember, upgrading your home’s entryway isn’t just about convenience; it’s about peace of mind, knowing your loved ones and belongings are protected, all while harnessing the clean, abundant energy of the sun. Whether you’re a tech enthusiast or simply want a more sustainable way to keep an eye on things, the best solar powered video doorbells offer a brilliant solution that’s both smart and eco-friendly. You’ve got the knowledge, you’ve seen the options – it’s time to bring that sunshine-powered security to your doorstep!

Now, imagine that feeling of effortless security, the sun doing the heavy lifting while you enjoy a clearer view of who’s arriving. You’ve navigated the features, compared the benefits, and you’re closer than ever to choosing the perfect addition to your home. Trust your gut, go with the one that resonates with your needs and budget, and get ready to experience a new level of connected living. Your future self, enjoying that worry-free peace of mind powered by the sun, will thank you for it. Go forth and secure your home, sustainably!

Leave a Comment